Current:Home > BackNorth Carolina court rules landlord had no repair duty before explosion-LoTradeCoin
North Carolina court rules landlord had no repair duty before explosion
View Date:2025-01-13 05:16:19
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — A tenant severely burned by a natural gas explosion inside his North Carolina rental home can’t successfully sue the landlord for negligence or other claims because there is no evidence the owner was made aware about needed house repairs and a possible gas leak inside, the state Supreme Court ruled on Friday.
By a 5-2 decision, justices reversed a split 2022 Court of Appeals panel that had declared claims filed by Anthony Terry could be tried alleging William V. Lucas failed in his duty to make home repairs and use reasonable care to inspect and maintain the property.
An explosion occurred in April 2017 when Terry turned on the light in the bathroom of his three-bedroom Durham home, setting him on fire. He was in a coma for four months and wasn’t released from medical care until the end of 2018, and years later still suffered constant pain and was bedbound most of the time, the prevailing Court of Appeals opinion said.
There was a water leak in the bathroom that an expert said had started seven years earlier, causing a hole in the floor and a corroded and rusted pipe in the crawlspace that supplied natural gas to the furnace. In the months before the explosion, the natural gas company and fire department came to the home twice to respond to reports of the smell of gas, Friday’s ruling said.
In the majority opinion that sided with then-Durham County Superior Court Judge Orlando Hudson’s ruling to dismiss Terry’s lawsuit, Associate Justice Tamara Barringer said that the common law creates no duty for a landlord to inspect a leased property — something that Lucas hadn’t done since Terry and his family occupied the property. Terry’s wife signed a lease for the home in the mid-2000s.
And the state’s Residential Rental Agreements Act, enacted in 1977, creates a landlord’s duty to make repairs, but only after receiving notice of the problem or acquiring actual knowledge about the repair, Barringer wrote. Terry never provided notice to Lucas about the hole or the water leak or told Lucas about the times firefighters or the gas company had come to investigate gas leak reports, she added.
Terry’s attorneys also argued that Lucas had a duty to comply with local housing codes, but the lack of notice about issues afforded “him no opportunity to take reasonable steps to remedy a violation,” Barringer wrote.
Associate Justice Allison Riggs, who wrote a dissenting opinion, said she would have allowed the case to go before a jury, saying the 1977 law does create a duty for a landlord in part to maintain a property’s facilities and appliances “in good and safe working order.”
The case record “demonstrates genuine issues about whether this landlord was negligent in the duty to maintain in ‘good and safe’ working order the gas-fired furnace and associated gas piping,” Riggs wrote. Associate Justice Anita Earls joined in Riggs’ opinion.
Natural gas provider Public Service Co. of North Carolina was a lawsuit defendant but claims against it were dismissed. The case attracted legal briefs from lawyers for several advocacy groups for the poor and for the North Carolina Association of Defense Attorneys.
veryGood! (33)
Related
- Colts' Kenny Moore II ridicules team's effort in loss to Bills
- North Carolina’s voter ID mandate taking effect this fall is likely dress rehearsal for 2024
- Trapped in hell: Palestinian civilians try to survive in northern Gaza, focus of Israel’s offensive
- Officer who shot Breonna Taylor says fellow officer fired ‘haphazardly’ into apartment during raid
- As CFP rankings punish SEC teams, do we smell bias against this proud and mighty league?
- NASCAR Cup Series Championship Race promises wide-open battle among rising stars
- Tupac Shakur has an Oakland street named for him 27 years after his death
- Israel deports thousands of Palestinian workers back to Gaza’s war zone
- Ryan Reynolds Clarifies Taylor Swift’s Role as Godmother to His Kids With Blake Lively
- Two former Northwestern football players say they experienced racism in program in 2000s
Ranking
- Moana 2 Star Dwayne Johnson Shares the Empowering Message Film Sends to Young Girls
- Jessica Simpson celebrates 6-year sobriety journey: 'I didn't respect my own power'
- A fire at a drug rehabilitation center in Iran kills 27 people, injures 17 others, state media say
- How much you pay to buy or sell a home may be about to change. Here's what you need to know
- Driver dies after crashing on hurricane-damaged highway in North Carolina
- Beloved Russian singer who criticized Ukraine war returns home. The church calls for her apology
- Jeff Bezos, after founding Amazon in a Seattle garage three decades ago, packs his bags for Miami
- Ken Mattingly, Apollo 16 astronaut who orbited the moon, dies at 87
Recommendation
-
32 things we learned in NFL Week 10: Who will challenge for NFC throne?
-
Vanderpump Rules Reveals Explosive Season 11 Teaser
-
Amazon founder billionaire Jeff Bezos announced he's leaving Seattle, moving to Miami
-
E-cigarette and tobacco use among high school students declines, CDC study finds
-
Reds honor Pete Rose with a 14-hour visitation at Great American Ball Park
-
Eric Trump returns to the witness stand in the family business’ civil fraud trial
-
Japan’s Princess Kako arrives in Peru to mark 150 years of diplomatic relations
-
Oregon Democratic US Rep. Earl Blumenauer reflects on 27 years in Congress and what comes next